Gathering Blue Novel Review: YA Trash

Gathering Blue by Lois Lowry

Believe me, no one wanted to love Gathering Blue more than I did, but I’m afraid I’m going to have to announce that the second book in the Giver Quartet is not very good. Not very good at all.

I’m shocked, particularly as the Giver was such a masterpiece. I was convinced this would be the first series of books since Harry Potter that has truly captured my imagination but it was just a little bit terrible. I know it’s a companion and not a sequel, but it still had zero characterisation, a very basic plot and was insultingly tedious.

The story follows Kira, a young teen with a twisted leg who is exceptionally good at embroidery. Her mother dies at the beginning of the novel and as her disability stops her from helping out with day-to-day tasks, the people of the village want to throw her into the wilderness to fend for herself. However, she is saved by the village Council who decide to take her on board as their official embroiderer due to her innate skill. What ensues is a tale of unconcealed oppression depicted as a plot twist and lots and lots (and lots) of detailed descriptions of thread.

This review might sound a little harsh but that is only because I feel so incredibly let down by Lois Lowry. What the heck happened from the first book to the second? How has an incredibly beautiful first novel descended into YA trash?

But hey, this might be the big build-up to the phenomenal piece of fiction that is Messenger, the third book in the series. Who knows? I’ll keep you posted.


This review is part of my 2017 Reading Challenge.


Emily created Dystopic in July 2012 after requiring an outlet for her love of dystopian and apocalyptic fiction. She is currently working on her debut novel 'These Unnatural Men' to be self-published in 2018.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *